Single RADIUS Class attribute supported by HP's Comware - Bug or Enhancement?

Nick Lowe nick.lowe at
Fri May 30 11:57:33 CEST 2014

The way I read the RFC, you either implement Class attribute support
completely or not at all in a NAS.

The SHOULD part therefore applies to supporting the Class attribute in
the first place, not to implementing it in a broken, non-standard way
that breaks the RFC.

The issue becomes a bug when Class support has been implemented and it
does not work as the standard says it should.

The RFC is very clear on the expected quantities for a particular
attribute type.

Clearly it cannot be unbounded due to resource constraints, but not
offering even a minimum of two Class attibutes cannot be right.


More information about the Freeradius-Users mailing list