mschap direct-to-Winbind different behaviour

[Jonathan Gazeley]

Hi folks,

I've been investigating switching my mschap authentications from 
ntlm_auth to use direct Winbind connections with libwbclient. It works 
fine for user authentications against AD but does not work for machine 
authentications against the same. The direct Winbind method returns an 
error from AD. Can anyone explain this?

FreeRADIUS 3.1.x built from git
Samba 4.2.3 from CentOS 7

Here's my mschap config:

mschap eduroammschap {

	# Either:
	ntlm_auth = "/usr/bin/ntlm_auth --request-nt-key 
--username=%{%{Stripped-User-Name}:-%{eduroammschap:User-Name}} 
--challenge=%{eduroammschap:Challenge} 
--nt-response=%{eduroammschap:NT-Response} "
	# Or:
	winbind_username = "%{%{Stripped-User-Name}:-%{eduroammschap:User-Name}}"
	winbind_domain = "%{eduroammschap:NT-Domain}"

	pool {
		start = ${thread[pool].start_servers}
		min = ${thread[pool].min_spare_servers}
		max = ${thread[pool].max_servers}
		spare = ${thread[pool].max_spare_servers}
		uses = 0
		retry_delay = 30
		lifetime = 86400
		cleanup_interval = 300
		idle_timeout = 600
	}
	allow_retry = no
	retry_msg = "Verify username and re-enter your password"
}




Debug using ntlm_auth:

(7)      Auth-Type eduroamlioneap {
(7)        eduroamlioneap - Peer sent packet with EAP method MSCHAPv2 (26)
(7)        eduroamlioneap - Calling submodule eap_mschapv2 to process data
(7)        eap_mschapv2 - Running Auth-Type MS-CHAP from file 
/etc/raddb/sites-enabled/eduroamlion-inner
(7)        eap_mschapv2 -   Auth-Type MS-CHAP {
(7)        eduroammschap -     Creating challenge hash with username: 
MONITOR899307$
(7)        eduroammschap -     Client is using MS-CHAPv2
(7)        eduroammschap -     Executing: /usr/bin/ntlm_auth 
--request-nt-key 
--username=%{%{Stripped-User-Name}:-%{eduroammschap:User-Name}} 
--challenge=%{eduroammschap:Challenge} 
--nt-response=%{eduroammschap:NT-Response} :
(7)        eduroammschap -     EXPAND 
--username=%{%{Stripped-User-Name}:-%{eduroammschap:User-Name}}
(7)        eduroammschap -     --> --username=MONITOR899307$
(7)        eduroammschap -     EXPAND --challenge=%{eduroammschap:Challenge}
(7)        eduroammschap -       Creating challenge hash with username: 
MONITOR899307$
(7)        eduroammschap -     --> --challenge=d6341cfb2d2e480e
(7)        eduroammschap -     EXPAND 
--nt-response=%{eduroammschap:NT-Response}
(7)        eduroammschap -     --> 
--nt-response=843e30991be16db3f688bff168572cb202bf0582b0713189
(7)        eduroammschap -     Program returned code (0) and output 
'NT_KEY: 4B6BB21FE18F7D003EFD4D39CFC5939A'
(7)        eduroammschap -     Adding MS-CHAPv2 MPPE keys
(7)        eduroammschap (ok)




Debug using direct Winbind:

(27)      Auth-Type eduroamlioneap {
(27)        eduroamlioneap - Peer sent packet with EAP method MSCHAPv2 (26)
(27)        eduroamlioneap - Calling submodule eap_mschapv2 to process data
(27)        eap_mschapv2 - Running Auth-Type MS-CHAP from file 
/etc/raddb/sites-enabled/eduroamlion-inner
(27)        eap_mschapv2 -   Auth-Type MS-CHAP {
(27)        eduroammschap -     Creating challenge hash with username: 
MONITOR899307$
(27)        eduroammschap -     Client is using MS-CHAPv2
(27)        eduroammschap -     EXPAND 
%{%{Stripped-User-Name}:-%{eduroammschap:User-Name}}
(27)        eduroammschap -     --> MONITOR899307$
(27)        eduroammschap -     EXPAND %{eduroammschap:NT-Domain}
(27)        eduroammschap -     --> UOB
(27)        eduroammschap -     Reserved connection (1)
(27)        eduroammschap -     sending authentication request 
user='MONITOR899307$' domain='UOB'
(27)        eduroammschap -     Released connection (1)
(27)        eduroammschap -     ERROR: No logon workstation trust 
account [0xC0000199]
(27)        eduroammschap -     ERROR: Password has expired.  User 
should retry authentication
(27)        eduroammschap (reject)


Thanks,
Jonathan

-- 
Jonathan Gazeley
Senior Systems Administrator
IT Services
University of Bristol