Authentication mschapv2 fail with samba 4.22.11 freeradius 4.0.65535, alternatives ?
Samba is a release version, freeradius is compiled from repository since I cannot get it to work with 3.2.10 Eventually a mikrotik AP will talk to freeradius that will ask samba DC to authenticate since https://securew2.com/blog/peap-mschapv2-vulnerability and therefore I have ntlm auth = ntlmv2_only What I am attempting is NOT to send cleartext or weak protocols around while authenticating to a samba server so, the question is: can you point me to an alternative "solution" to bind authentication between freeradius and samba DC ? I am reading of EAP-TLS, is it the right track ?
On Nov 12, 2026, at 8:23 AM, Damiano via Freeradius-Users <freeradius-users@lists.freeradius.org> wrote:
Samba is a release version, freeradius is compiled from repository since I cannot get it to work with 3.2.10 Eventually a mikrotik AP will talk to freeradius that will ask samba DC to authenticate
since https://securew2.com/blog/peap-mschapv2-vulnerability and therefore I have ntlm auth = ntlmv2_only
What I am attempting is NOT to send cleartext or weak protocols around while authenticating to a samba server
If you use ntlm over a secure network, it's not so bad. i.e. a management-only VLAN.
so, the question is: can you point me to an alternative "solution" to bind authentication between freeradius and samba DC ? I am reading of EAP-TLS, is it the right track ?
EAP-TLS is nice if you have a whole suite of tools to manage certificates, etc. That's what the secureW2 people are selling. But if you don't want that, MS-CHAP is fine. I've been leaning on the Microsoft people to implement fixes for that, but I have only so much influence on a large company. Alan DeKok.
I have found this example of use https://www.cavanasystems.com/blog/using-freeradius-to-perform-eap-tls-and-p... do you think it is a viable solution to authenticate users that use a mikrotik AP ? Thank you
participants (2)
-
Alan DeKok -
ced@comunedilonigo.it