Freeradius / NAS issue

[Andy Billington]

Thankyou Alan!

I don't want to shout at the NAS owner (we rely on them for customer
connections on a private DSL network and the other sites are fine!)
without backup / confidence that I'm not making mistakes.

The users connect, both the logs earlier and now the debug output show
Accept messages going out to the NAS correctly, and as i said most of
our user community connects without issue. Which lead me to say it's
not RADIUS, but I was given a "it's your RADIUS" response by our
provider.

I guess my first step tomorrow is to make sure the NAS receives the
Access-Accept for all sites and then give it to them to figure out why
some are being marked as Reject by the NAS and some are OK and do as i
said about "new" user setups.

As I said previously, Thankyou very much for your assistance - the
accounting packet issue i can sort given time (and offline) and
hopefully i wont need to trouble anyone further. All ideas gratefully
recieved though!

Andy

On 09/08/2007, Alan DeKok <aland at deployingradius.com> wrote:
> Andy Billington wrote:
> > Was thinking about setting up another FR instance, separate IP and
> > with just pure text (users) info but am not sure - what concerns me is
> > seeing a few mails that have same symptoms (connect starts, then
> > restarts after 10s)
>
>   Do those users get connected at *all*?  If they do, then the problem
> is the NAS.  It's being told to connect them, it does, and then 10s
> later, it disconnects them.
>
>   *Please* ensure that the problem is something other than RADIUS before
> poking your FreeRADIUS configuration.  If the NAS receives the
> Access-Accept and lets the user on, DON'T touch your RADIUS
> configuration.  Buy a NAS that works.
>
>   Alan DeKok.
> -
> List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html
>