Jelle Langbroek wrote:
I can tell you that with my tests, I figured out that it's happening with all sorts of clients (MacOSX, XP, Vista).
The supplicant's aren't involved here. It's the NAS that retransmits the RADIUS packets.
It appears only to be happing with the WAP54G (and now the WRT54GL you say). When I replaced the WAP54G with a WAP200, the errors disappeared with the same clients.
i.e. the WAP54G is broken. It doesn't do RADIUS properly.
I tested this on many locations with many different clients and everywhere the same results. It must be the WAP54G then.
Yes.
I'm still using those AP's and I keep getting the error in the logs. It's indeed quite random. The error seems not harmful (although the sourcecode of freeRadius says the AP is broken).
:) It's a common complaint on this list. Some issues are FreeRADIUS bugs. Others are broken NASes. I'm in the process of putting together a RADIUS validation test suite, so that manufacturers can see if their products are compliant *before* shipping them. Alan DeKok.