Hi, Thanks for the reply. What I have about the Alcatel VSA is 1- From its customer documentation; General Vendor ID 637 is used for 7302 ISAM. The vendor specific attribute type has a length of two bytes long where the highest byte is the project ID and the lowest byte is the project specific attribute ID. The project ID 7 is assigned to 7302 ISAM project. This means that the vendor specific attribute range from 1792 to 2047 will be used for the 7302 ISAM. VRF-Name • Vendor Type: 1792 • Vendor Length: 4 < length < 35 • Vendor Value: STRING • Packet: Access-Accept VLAN-ID • Vendor Type: 1793 • Vendor Length: 7 • Vendor Value: INTEGER • Packet: Access-Accept . . . 2- The complete dictionary file from TRS ( Technical Requirements Specific) ; # # Alcatel ESAM's VSA's, from TRS # # VENDOR Alcatel-ESAM 637 BEGIN-VENDOR Alcatel-ESAM ATTRIBUTE A-ESAM-VRF-Name 0x0700 string ATTRIBUTE A-ESAM-Vlan-Id 0x0701 integer ATTRIBUTE A-ESAM-QOS-Profile-Name 0x0702 string ATTRIBUTE A-ESAM-QOS-Params 0x0703 string ATTRIBUTE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause 0x0704 integer # # Integer Translations # # A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Values VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Unknown-VRF 1 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause No-VRF 2 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Unknown-Vlan 3 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause No-Vlan 4 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Unknown-Pool-Id 5 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Pool-Admin-Locked 6 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause No-Pool-Id 7 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Pool-VRF-Inconsistent 8 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Unknown-QOS-Profile 9 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause QOS-Params-Syntax-Err 10 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause IP-Addr-In-Use 11 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause No-IP-Addr-Available 12 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause No-User-IP-Addr 13 VALUE A-ESAM-Termination-Cause Missing-Attributes 14 #VSA for Operator Authentication ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Maintenance 0x0600 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Provisioning 0x0601 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_TL1_Security 0x0602 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Test 0x0603 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_AAA 0x0709 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_ATM 0x070A integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Alarm 0x070B integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_DHCP 0x070C integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_EQP 0x070D integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_IGMP 0x070E integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_CPEProxy 0x070F integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_IP 0x0710 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_PPPoE 0x0711 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_QoS 0x0712 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_SWMgt 0x0713 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Transport 0x0714 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_VLAN 0x0715 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_XDSL 0x0716 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Security 0x0717 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Cluster 0x0718 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Prompt 0x0719 string ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Pwd_Timeout 0x071A integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_Description 0x071B string ATTRIBUTE A_AL_SLOT_NUMBERING 0x071C integer ####FTTU TL1 values############################################### ATTRIBUTE A_AL_MAINTENANCE_BACKWARD 0x0705 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_PROVISIONING_BACKWARD 0x0706 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_TL1_SECURITY_BACKWARD 0x0707 integer ATTRIBUTE A_AL_TEST_BACKWARD 0x0708 integer ################################################################### # A_AL_Maintenance Values VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-No-Maint-Priv-Level 0 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-1 1 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-2 2 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-3 3 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-4 4 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-5 5 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-6 6 VALUE A_AL_Maintenance Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-7 7 # A_AL_Provisioning Values VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-No-Maint-Priv-Level 0 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-1 1 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-2 2 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-3 3 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-4 4 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-5 5 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-6 6 VALUE A_AL_Provisioning Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-7 7 # A_AL_Security Values VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-No-Maint-Priv-Level 0 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-1 1 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-2 2 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-3 3 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-4 4 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-5 5 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-6 6 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-7 7 # A_AL_Test Values VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-No-Maint-Priv-Level 0 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-1 1 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-2 2 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-3 3 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-4 4 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-5 5 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-6 6 VALUE A_AL_Test Alcatel-Maint-Priv-Level-7 7 # A_AL_AAA Value VALUE A_AL_AAA Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_AAA Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_AAA Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_AAA Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_ATM Value VALUE A_AL_ATM Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_ATM Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_ATM Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_ATM Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_Alarm Value VALUE A_AL_Alarm Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_Alarm Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_Alarm Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_Alarm Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_DHCP Value VALUE A_AL_DHCP Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_DHCP Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_DHCP Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_DHCP Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_EQP Value VALUE A_AL_EQP Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_EQP Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_EQP Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_EQP Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_IGMP Value VALUE A_AL_IGMP Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_IGMP Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_IGMP Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_IGMP Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_CPEProxy Value VALUE A_AL_CPEProxy Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_CPEProxy Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_CPEProxy Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_CPEProxy Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_IP Value VALUE A_AL_IP Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_IP Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_IP Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_IP Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_PPPoE Value VALUE A_AL_PPPoE Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_PPPoE Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_PPPoE Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_PPPoE Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_QoS Value VALUE A_AL_QoS Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_QoS Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_QoS Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_QoS Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_SWMgt Value VALUE A_AL_SWMgt Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_SWMgt Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_SWMgt Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_SWMgt Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_Transport Value VALUE A_AL_Transport Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_Transport Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_Transport Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_Transport Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_VLAN Value VALUE A_AL_VLAN Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_VLAN Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_VLAN Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_VLAN Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_XDSL Value VALUE A_AL_XDSL Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_XDSL Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_XDSL Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_XDSL Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_Security Value VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_Security Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_Cluster Value VALUE A_AL_Cluster Alcatel-No-Priv 0 VALUE A_AL_Cluster Alcatel-Read-Priv 1 VALUE A_AL_Cluster Alcatel-Write-Priv 2 VALUE A_AL_Cluster Alcatel-RW-Priv 3 # A_AL_Cluster Value VALUE A_AL_SLOT_NUMBERING SLOT_NUMBERING_TYPE 1 VALUE A_AL_SLOT_NUMBERING SLOT_NUMBERING_POSITION 2 VALUE A_AL_SLOT_NUMBERING SLOT_NUMBERING_LEGACY 3 END-VENDOR Alcatel-ESAM Does this answer your question ? Thanks. Salim Engin On Fri, Sep 11, 2009 at 12:40 PM, Alan DeKok <aland@deployingradius.com>wrote:
Salim Engin wrote:
I have problem in adding new VSA dictionary file into Freeradius 2.1.6. Below you can find the steps I performed; ... According to my analysis, freeradius does not like the hex values in the VSA dictionary file i.e : 0x0700 .
In 2.1.x, it can handle hex values just fine.
So I tried to make it decimal which is 1792 but still getting the same error message. It seems those attribute numbers should be in a lower range, because if I start from 1 , and I don't get the message in question. But in this case, the attribute becomes unknown resulting in having not applied while user authentication.
The default VSA format is an 8 bit "type" field. 0x0700 doesn't fit within an 8-bit field.
What is the format for Alcatel-Esam attributes? Do you have documentation from Alcatel saying what the format is, or a dictionary from another vendor describing the format?
Alan DeKok. - List info/subscribe/unsubscribe? See http://www.freeradius.org/list/users.html