Thanks for your quick reply. I did not think I should dump my entire configuration and debug log for this very specific question. That was in consideration for all who would try to help, as I think this is a very specific question I am posing. My problem is that the update is not affected unless i put a reject statement as well. What I am expecting is my update reply statement to update the reply and not return noop, since it would have operated upon the reply. Is this not a clear question? I do not want to frustrate anyone, but you are replying in a very specific way, which shows that you are more interested in being right than helping someone out. I respect your authority in all things FreeRADIUS but surely you cannot expect anyone to be on the same level as you in this mailing list, otherwise there would be no point in having a Users sub-forum.